Choose wood for lowest upfront cost; vinyl for lowest lifetime maintenance
If you want the lowest upfront cost and enjoy maintaining a natural wood look, pressure-treated pine or cedar is the straightforward pick: national installed pricing near $25–$37 per linear ft for 6 ft privacy. Plan to stain or seal every few years and replace boards as they age.
Vinyl privacy fencing makes sense when you want zero staining, uniform color for HOA compliance, or long warranty coverage in humid climates. At $28–$41 per linear ft installed, vinyl costs more today—but skipping $200–$400 maintenance cycles every few years often closes the gap within a decade.